Literature, Gender and Social Expectations: have fairytales evolved to reinforce or contest gender roles?
Updated: Oct 22
The history of fairytales: how stories reinforce or challenge gender roles?
Fairytales have presented themselves in various ways and have evolved over hundreds of years - Folks, myths, legends, fables and all kinds of different forms of narratives have been passed on from generation to generation primarily to entertain and amuse people but also to teach moral lessons. They began as oral tales that were spoken through poetry or prose, originally intended for adults however, have been known for being targeted at children.
The first known written form of these tales was in the 1600s by Charles Perrault, a contemporary of Louis XIV. Perrault composed elegant odes and portraits of powerful people that were aimed at an adult and aristocratic readership; both his style and his stories’ morals were the product of careful reflection.
Fairy tales appeared as a subcategory of folk tales and were transformed into literary tales after the invention of the printing press, addressing the tastes and functions of court society. The literary translations of these fairytales that were made for childhood consumption were brought in around the eighteenth century, the had been purged and rewritten to appeal to children.
This also meant rewriting them to fit with social ideology.
This occurred through the Grimm brothers, who took the oral stories and wrote them in ways that made them dark and twisted. Whilst they were two people in a long line of people who re-iterated and recorded these stories, it is Walt Disney that changed the trajectory of these traditional stories and turned them into the stories they are today with a distinctive perspective on gender roles.

Femininity, masculinity and cultural identity: the “Disney-fication” of the traditional fairytale
Walt Disney began adapting fairytales in the early 1920s, for short animations. Disney established the Laugh-O-gram Films company in 1922 to animate modernised fairy tales with a Jazz Age flair. One of the last of these Laugh-O-gram fairy tales—made before the enterprise went bankrupt and Walt headed for Hollywood in 1923—was Cinderella. This is not to be mistaken with the feature film animation version of Cinderella, which was released in 1950.
Disney had the rights to the Grimm fairytales but wanted to make upbeat stories with the trademark “happily ever after” so changed the genre conventions. The first feature film, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, followed the story of a young girl who was exiled into the woods by her evil stepmother, who was jealous of the girl’s beauty. Snow White took refuge at the home of seven enchanted dwarves until her stepmother found her and gave her a poisoned apple when disguised as an elderly lady. Snow White was comatose until the prince came to save her with “true loves’ kiss”, which woke her from her slumber.
The theme of youth and beauty being symbolic of a heroine and age being symbolic of something evil and ugly, pitting women against each other is a running theme throughout many early Disney films and the concept of female weakness that can only be saved by a man is a theme throughout. The Grimm tale took a more violent approach, however Disney’s version took on a more romantic approach, focusing on the generic love story where the young girl was saved by the prince.
As mentioned, Cinderella is a Laugh-O-Gram that was adapted into the feature film we know today. Cinderella (1950) was one of Walt Disney’s most highly-anticipated films. Not since Bambi (1942) had he released a feature-length animated story. After World War II, audiences were impatient for something reminiscent of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937), a film that had rescued their hearts from the Great Depression.
Cinderella was a young woman, abused by her stepmother and treated like a maid following her father’s death, when Prince Charming was looking for a wife, he invited all the women, Cinderella’s stepmother and the “ugly stepsisters” included. They destroyed Cinderella’s ballgown, resulting in her fearing she cannot go, however when met with her “fairy godmother” her rags were transformed into a beautiful ballgown and glass slippers. She danced with the prince until midnight, where the spell was broken and her gown turned back into rags. She left without telling the prince her name and he resorted to finding the glass slipper and trying it on every woman in the kingdom until he found Cinderella. Once again, she was saved by the prince and taken away from her evil stepmother and stepsisters.
Both of these stories follow the same pattern, the young, beautiful girl is treated poorly by the villain (an older, “uglier” woman) and has to be saved by a man. This trajectory was repeated throughout the stories, pitting women against each other and allowing the younger women to be perceived with fragility and needed a man to give them a lifestyle beyond the domestic sphere. These aren’t single occurrences, with the likes of The Little Mermaid and Sleeping Beauty also having these instances where the young woman needs a man to save her and she is forced into domesticated roles.
Characters who resist conventional expectations
Newer Disney princess movies such as Pocahontas, Mulan, and Brave have female characters who show more masculine characteristics rather than female characteristics. Mulan was more masculine and was in the army, trying to prove herself to the men by hiding the fact that she was a woman (by pretending to be a man). This is where toxic gender roles are reinforced.
This narrative that Disney has set, by twisting these stories into a genre that demonises strong women, had to eventually force female characters into masculine roles in order to comprehend the strength that women possess. The masculine characters are strong, brave and domineering, and when the female characters take on these characteristics, they are either villainised (by not being conventionally “pretty” and taking on the dominant role) or they have mistaken identities.
It has only been recently, with the likes of Frozen (2013) and Moana (2016), that women have been able to take on dominant characteristics, without either needing a man to save her, or without being villainised for it. The stories take on a narrative where a higher power is the villain rather than a woman jealous of a young woman’s beauty or power.
There are remaking’s of these older stories, for example Once Upon A Time (2011-2018), where the characters are from fairy tales, but their stories are twisted and they are given humanistic narratives where the villains have more complex backstories to justify their actions. Angela Carter’s short story collection, The Bloody Chamber, is a feminist retelling of traditional fairy tales in which Carter portrays these expressions of sexuality and exploits the fairy tale form ironically to highlight the power imbalances in heterosexual relationships and to empower women to liberate themselves from the oppressive force of male sexuality. This book was published in the 1970s and was deemed controversial. This could be due to the fact it was deemed unacceptable for women in fairytales to be portrayed as strong characters.
It is astonishing to see that it has taken this long for these stories, which began as oral folk tales in the 1600s, to become positive of women’s experiences and enables women to be accepted and valued regardless of age or attractiveness. It shows how, despite feminism making progress, these innate gender roles still have an impact today, particularly on the aging process of women in Hollywood which is the very place where these stories were made famous.



Comments